Underfloor heating is becoming an increasingly popular choice in households or offices. This is due mainly to its energy efficiency and cost-saving fees.If you are in the process of having one, the underfloor heating installers might have already informed you that there are two different types of systems to choose from: an electric (dry one) and a hydronic( wet system). Despite their distinct mechanisms and specific features, they are both valid options and below we highlighted their pros and cons to help you determine which one is best for you.
What is electric floor heating?
Simply put, an electric floor system is a network of electricity conducting wires entwined through the floor's surface, and it is generated by thermal energy. This system is easy to install, so you can either choose an Underfloor heating company to do it or you can attempt a DIY project.
Pros and cons of Electric floor heating
One of the main pros of electric floor heating is its energy efficiency and being inexpensive to install.
Other benefits of an electric underfloor system are:
- Can be easily installed in existing buildings and renovations
- Can be both primary and supplemental heat
- It requires minimal floor elevation
Cons:
- It is not advised for whole-house heating
- Depending on location and square footage, the operation cost can be high
What is Hydronic floor heating?
Hydronic heating is put in motion by circulating heated water through a network of pipes b that require a connection to a boiler.
Hydronic floor-heating systems should be installed when a house is being built, as, unlike electric systems, they are more laborious to install and are not recommended for remodeling projects.
Pros and cons of Hydronic floor heating
Hydronic floor systems are ideal for whole-house heating, opposite to electric ones.
Other pros of choosing hydronic floor heating:
- Low overall operating cost, as the cost per square foot drops with the increase of the square footage
- Can be primary or supplemental heat.
Cons:
- Expensive and difficult to install- you need a plumber as this cannot be a DIY project.
- High maintenance- in the case of an underfloor heating repair, the cost can be very high when it comes to the hydronic system.
- Lack of energy efficiency
Conclusion
When it comes to investing in your comfort, you want to make the right choice. Underfloor heating systems are the go-to for many new-build homes and both hydronic and electric heating are valid options. However, make sure you consider the cost, energy efficiency and overall maintenance when choosing the right one for you.
